Monday, May 16, 2011

CLAT 2011 : You HAVE to be KIDDING me!

I had been waiting for the 15th of May for quite some time now. Having taken a series of Mock Tests and scored increasingly well in every one of them, I had the momentum with me and in all sincerity, I have never been more anxious about any exam that I had to sit for than that of the Common Law Admission Test (CLAT) 2011.

For those who haven't heard of CLAT, you really should. Its a brilliantly structured exam which tests the all round ability of an individual - Comprehension, Practicality, Sensibility, Speed and more importantly, Stamina! Although it lasts for just the 120 minutes, it drains the living hell out of you. CLAT is a real test of how capable a citizen you are of the country - how aware, how potent and how orgnanized. It is a race against time, before the word go. THAT is the intensity with which the storm called CLAT comes and zooms past.



CLAT 2011 had many interesting changes from the previous years. No Legal Knowledge - which meant less of Latin mumbo jumbo and more of Legal Aptitude. Personally, I thought it was a BRILLIANT idea! Apart from that, we had the GK section cut down to current affairs of the last 12 months, another excellent way to make the paper more scoring and interesting. It seemed as though a paper with such considerable changes would definitely make 150 (out of 200) an achievable score with a little amount of "hard work" and little luck here and there!


Luck happens when preparation meets opportunity. My preparations were dead on. I had never prepared more for an exam. CLAT had been the only thing in my mind for the last month and guess what I get for opportunity? Peanuts.


Come May 15th, everything changed.


The paper setters clearly had some personal vendetta against any student taking this year's exam because simply put, no one, and I MEAN NO ONE could ever complete the 200 marks in two hours - include the paper setters themselves. No personal offenses meant but, you HAVE to be KIDDING me!
The English section had 4 comprehensions - each about a page and a half long. Yes, you read that - PAGE and a HALF! But that would still be okay if there were considerable number of grammar based questions but lo! Grammar seems to have been playing Dominoes with Justice somewhere FAAAR away from the minds of the setters. Indeed, the English section with 36 Comprehension based long questions had absolutely NO justification. 

One of my friends texted "WHAT are these people trying to prove!". Dead on, my friend, DEAD ON.



The current affairs section was still okay. Some questions here and there which were a little hard but on the whole, no arguments. The questions were really well selected.


But whoever thought a Lawyer needs to be a Mathematician definitely shouldn't have set this year's Maths section. But since we are riding the Unfortunate Ship, that very thing happened. I had never taken 30 mins to solve the maths section but that was exactly what happened. 

Still okay, it CAN happen. But what was in store for the next two sections simply couldn't be justified.

Logical Reasoning has traditionally been an equal mixture of Analytical and Critical Reasoning but somehow the entire section felt like truckloads of Essays set solely for the purpose of ensuring the students had absolutely no chance of touching the next section at all. After the first 5 Analytical Reasoning questions, which were moderate, about 40 questions had huge paragraphs - 7 to 8 lines - more, if not less, and not ONCE did they give interlinked questions that could at least save us some time.

And probably the best time to punch in the Ekta Kapoor patented "Kyuuuuun?! Mujhe Jawab chahiye!".


WBNUJS had not yet finished with us. If all this seemed to be pretty huge to have been completed in 2 hours, we had YET another section with MORE paragraphs, essays and MORE ENGLISH than a Britisher could take in one day.

45 Principle - Situation - Comprehension based questions which tested more of your luck than comprehensive skills since about 99.99% of the students had on other option but randomly circle the blanks left with just a minute to go. So much for aspiring to be a lawyer - Legal Section left blank. 



Now my question to dear paper setters would be simple. What was the paper about? I'd have commended it if it were tough, but it wasn't. It was easy but, just HUGE. So is this a clear indication that many of the applicants who are coming from the regional boards and who didn't have English as their first language do not deserve a chance at the National Law Colleges? If so, why? Being a proficient lawyer indeed needs a good understanding of the language but is THAT the ONLY consideration? Because, no matter how much you deny, that was the ONLY thing that the paper reflected.


If CLAT 2009 and 2010 were encouraging to "fair competition", CLAT 2011 was the exact opposite. There may be better justifications with the organizers against my arguments but with due respect, I don't understand the basis of the exam. Ultimately, everyone had to randomly circle 20-30 questions minimum without reading the questions at all in some cases. So do we leave the future of the country to rest upon luck? Do we get so naive in our approach that we don't test the aspirant's real potential and test how much he can get away with?


There are many unanswered questions which linger in the mind of the applicants after the disaster called CLAT 2011. Thank you for shattering our confidence and effectively leaving 500 future lawyers with a very questionable start to their careers. If that was indeed your motive, you did well. But unfortunately, the least it does is ensure justice - probably the sole purpose of the exam. 

Irony, they say, is everywhere.  
They, are right.