Tuesday, December 27, 2011

E-Commerce : Restricted space

Not everything can be done online; commonsense tells you that, doesn't it?

I was reading this article today on how e-commerce took a major hit this year. The success stories of Flipkart and Snapdeal over the last few years meant the general notion of a "prospective boom" in the online retail sector. However, in spite of Venture Capitalists and Private Equity investors pumping in around $500 million this year, several major players have taken a hit and have been forced to shut down.

Among the list of names that I came across, Nammagroceries.com, Harisabzi.com and Subzimandi.in caught my eye. Reason being, the odd thought that you can sell groceries online.

I mean, its one thing to see that the number of people using internet in the country has been growing hundred-fold in the last half-decade or so but is there even a rationale behind thinking people are going to buy vegetables online?

Of course, you might find some widely dispersed customers who prefer the convenience (if at all) but lets go back to my keynote premise; not everything can be done online.

You might be expecting a possible reason behind that argument by now. Well, its simple. Vegetables have been (in the Indian context, at least) one of those commodities which people need to be present physically, in order to buy. Sure, some people choose to appoint their domestic helps to do the job. In other cases, they choose the local grocery retail outlet (Food Bazaar, Big Bazaar, Reliance Fresh, etc) instead of the actual subzi mandi but you can't tell what you're going to get unless you are actually present, buying it yourself that which satisfies you most.

Another example in this category would be about selling clothes online. I'm sure eBay will disagree with me at this point but, again, choosing a general line of thought, you won't see people sitting at home and ordering clothes instead of actually going to the outlets and buying them physically.

Two arguments that prop up against me now are : a) It is convenient and time saving. b) There are cash-on-delivery facilities which don't make it binding for you to pay unless it meets your desired satisfaction levels.

And here is how I counter those arguments.
a) Its a matter of perspective. People choose to "save time" from "work" for "leisure activities". Now when was the last time you "wanted" to not spend some time enjoying an item of luxury - an hour of a really good movie, perhaps? because you would rather work?

Yeah, never!

Paying bills standing in lines is waste of time. We substitute that with online payment, sure.
Buying electronic gadgets, reality deals, books, etc. are as good buying from a store as they are sitting at home and ordering online. We substitute physical labor with the comfort of ordering from home.

But in several cultures here, going out to shop vegetables is still considered as one of the very few existing luxury practices that didn't include the use of a gadget. Hence, people choose the local subzi mandi.


b) I'm not convinced with cash on delivery being the ideal solution for meeting your desired satisfaction levels. Its rare that you find something wrong in a gadget or a book that you might reject accepting it. Its not that you order such items almost daily either. But, with groceries (which are, in many households, a part of the daily shopping list) you can't just sit back at home and keep rejecting deliveries one after the other as long as that potato doesn't have the black little spot or the onion didn't smell so un-fresh.

So, there you go. Budding entrepreneurs that our country is so filled with, I am sure all of you have beautiful minds on your shoulders working and finding newer ways to make some money. But, maybe its time the world slowed down a little and respected the necessity of some basic traditions and practices.

And not expect people to order vegetables online! I mean, really?

No comments:

Post a Comment